In a recent article, Sir Robin Jacob, Former Lord Justice of Appeal sets out 14 rules for writing judgements. Sir Jacob touches on his experiences with judgements and why he believes modern judgements have become so ling.

The fact is that modern judgments have become far too long.
Whether at first instance (where fact-finding will inevitably increase
length somewhat) or on appeal I hazard that they are on average
nearly twice as long as they were 50 years ago.

Life is too short to read modern judgments.

A JUDICIAL CODE FOR JUDGMENT-WRITING

  1. Judgments should be as concise as reasonably possible;
  2. Keep sentences short. Never use two words
    where one will do;
  3. Beware subordinate clauses;
  4. Keep the number of authorities you cite down to what
    is necessary. You are not writing to show how clever or
    learned you are;
  5. If you quote from an authority, keep the quotation as
    short as possible. Seldom, if ever, use more than two
    sentences. The same applies when quoting from a
    key document;
  6. Keep your recital of facts to what is necessary;
  7. Avoid any detail that is not important;
  8. When you have done your first draft judgment, go over
    it and cut out unnecessary words or see if you can say
    something more succinctly;
  9. Then do it again;
  10. Empathise with your key readers—who are the parties;
  11. Eschew trying to lay down the law on the subject in
    hand for all future generations;
  12. The losing party is the more important and you need
    to cover each point he or she makes. But, save for the
    main point(s), all others only need brief mention and
    disposal. This is particularly true at first instance—do
    not let a large number of points lead to prolixity;
  13. Overall, try to make the whole thing at least readable, if
    not a page-turner.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay updated, informed and entertained.

Get the latest updates and events from the Scottish legal sector directly to your inbox every Friday.